Business Continuity Planning for Insurance Firms
Business continuity planning tends to get treated as a document that sits in a drawer until an auditor or an insurer asks for it. For an insurance firm, it deserves more attention than that, because the firm's own reputation depends on being reachable and functional precisely when clients are dealing with a loss of their own.
Business continuity planning for an insurance firm should identify which systems are critical to client service, such as the broker management system, phone lines, and email, set recovery time targets for each, and document the specific steps staff take during an outage. This should be tested periodically, not just written once, and paired with a tested backup strategy so recovery targets are realistic rather than aspirational.
Start with what actually needs to stay running
Not every system in the office is equally critical. A continuity plan should rank systems by how quickly their loss affects client service, since that ranking drives everything else in the plan, from backup frequency to failover connectivity investment.
- Tier 1, restore within hours: broker management system, phone lines, email
- Tier 2, restore within a day: file storage, accounting software, internal document templates
- Tier 3, restore within a few days: archived records, historical reporting tools
Setting realistic recovery time targets
A recovery time objective is only useful if the backup and infrastructure behind it can actually meet it. Promising same-day recovery of a broker management server without a tested backup and recovery process in place is a plan on paper only. Our backup and disaster recovery services, built on Acronis Cyber Protect Cloud, are designed around specific recovery time targets agreed with the client rather than a generic backup schedule.
Planning for a ransomware scenario specifically
Ransomware deserves its own line item in a continuity plan because it behaves differently from a typical hardware failure: backups themselves can be targeted, and recovery decisions involve more than restoring data, including whether systems were compromised beyond the encrypted files. Our ransomware recovery guide covers the recovery process in more depth, and immutable, offline-capable backups are a core defence against backups being encrypted alongside production data.
Do you have a tested continuity plan, or just an assumption?
We help insurance firms build and test continuity plans around realistic recovery targets, not guesswork.
Start a Continuity ReviewCommunication during an outage
Clients calling during an outage need a consistent answer, not confusion. A continuity plan should include a communication plan: who updates clients, what channel is used if phones or email are affected, and how staff are kept informed as the situation develops. A brief, honest update goes a long way toward preserving client trust compared to silence.
Working with carriers during an outage
Carriers a brokerage works with need to know if the brokerage cannot process transactions or communicate normally during an extended outage, particularly if time-sensitive renewals or claims are affected. Identifying key carrier contacts ahead of time, as part of the continuity plan itself, saves scrambling for phone numbers during an actual incident.
Testing the plan, not just writing it
A continuity plan that has never been tested is a guess. Periodic tests, whether a simulated outage, a test restore of the broker management system's data, or a tabletop walkthrough with staff, reveal gaps that look fine on paper but fall apart in practice, such as a backup that takes far longer to restore than expected.
Insurance and regulatory considerations
Many cyber insurance policies expect a documented continuity or incident response plan as part of underwriting, and some regulators expect firms to have reasonable continuity measures in place, though the specifics vary. Confirming what a particular insurer or regulator expects should go directly to that insurer or to FSRA, since general guidance like this article cannot substitute for a firm's specific policy terms or licensing obligations.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a continuity plan be tested?
At least annually, with a more frequent check on backup restore testing specifically. Significant changes to systems or staff should also trigger a review of the plan.
What is the difference between a backup plan and a continuity plan?
A backup plan protects the data. A continuity plan covers the full picture, including which systems get restored first, how staff communicate during an outage, and how clients and carriers are kept informed.
Does our cyber insurance policy require a continuity plan?
Many policies expect one as part of underwriting, but specific requirements vary by carrier and policy. Confirm directly with your insurer rather than assuming.
What is the first system we should prioritize restoring after an outage?
Most brokerages prioritize the broker management system, phone lines, and email first, since those directly affect the ability to serve clients during the outage.
Joshua Arimoro
Joshua Arimoro is the Principal Consultant at Nickel City Tech Solutions, a managed IT and cybersecurity provider based in Lively, Ontario, serving businesses across Greater Sudbury and Northern Ontario. He works hands-on with Microsoft 365, server and network infrastructure, endpoint management, and backup and recovery for small and mid-sized organisations.
More about our teamBuild a continuity plan that actually works when tested
We help insurance firms design and test recovery plans built around realistic timelines and real backup infrastructure.
Related services, locations, and resources
Related services
- Cybersecurity Services
Endpoint protection, MFA, email filtering, and M365 hardening.
- Backup & Disaster Recovery
Backup strategy, monitoring, and recovery testing.
- Managed IT Services
Proactive monitoring, patching, and predictable monthly support.
- Microsoft 365 Support
Exchange, Teams, SharePoint, OneDrive, and licensing.
Related service areas
Related resources
- IT Support for Insurance Brokerages in Northern Ontario
Insurance brokerages handle sensitive client and financial data all day, every day, through a broker manage…
- Cybersecurity for Insurance Brokerages: A Practical Guide
Brokerages sell cyber insurance to their clients while sometimes overlooking their own exposure. Here is a …
- Secure Client Document Sharing for Insurance Brokerages
Policy documents and claims paperwork move constantly between brokers, clients, and carriers. Plain email a…
